Skip to main content

‘Consultancy Agreement’ turns out to be agency after all: goodwill compensation claim fails for lack of substantiation

Thomas van Vugt
4 min read

Share blog

In brief

  • A French trading company worked for years for a flavour enhancer producer from the Zaan region under a 'Consultancy Agreement' that expressly stated it was not an agency.
  • The subdistrict court judge rules that it is an agency agreement nonetheless: the label the parties put on their contract is not decisive.
  • Of the almost €190,000 claimed, less than €9,000 remains: the claim for goodwill compensation is rejected because the agent failed to specify which customers it had brought in.

What was the case about?

The parties had worked together since 2010. The French company initially carried out market research and later went on to recruit customers in Africa, the Middle East and Turkey. In return, it received a fixed annual fee plus a variable fee based on the producer’s turnover in those regions. The variable fee only applied above a threshold and was capped. The collaboration ended in 2023, with a contractual arrangement that commission would continue to be paid for another six months.

The French company brought proceedings before the subdistrict court judge of the District Court of North Holland, who delivered judgment on 16 July 2026 (ECLI:NL:RBNHO:2026:10539). It claimed €49,000 in commission for the period after the end of the agreement and goodwill compensation of €140,773. Dutch contract lawyer Thomas van Vugt discusses the judgment.

Label or reality?

The producer’s defence relied mainly on the contract, which stated in black and white that the parties did not want an agency relationship. Moreover, the French party received instructions and the producer’s director attended meetings.

According to the subdistrict court judge, that reasoning does not hold water. Whether there is an agency agreement does not depend on what the parties call it, but on whether the statutory requirements of Article 7:428(1) of the Dutch Civil Code (DCC) are met: acting as an intermediary, for remuneration, without subordination. How the parties actually performed the agreement also counts.

A turnover bonus is also commission

The most interesting point is the remuneration. The producer argued that no commission was paid per customer recruited, only a fixed amount plus a bonus on total regional turnover. In 2015, the Amsterdam Court of Appeal held that a purely fixed daily fee does not amount to agency (ECLI:NL:GHAMS:2015:3847).

This case was different. According to the subdistrict court judge, commission per customer is not a requirement. There must, however, be a link between the agent’s efforts and its remuneration. Put simply: the more customers the French party brought in, the higher the turnover and therefore the higher its bonus. That others also contributed to that turnover makes no difference. Nor does the fact that the parties called it a ‘sales incentive’. The instructions and the attendance at meetings do not make the agent subordinate either: a principal is entitled to give its agent directions.

The threshold also applies after termination

The parties agreed that commission was still owed, but not on the amount. The French company wanted the turnover threshold to be disregarded and referred to an interim judgment of the ’s-Hertogenbosch Court of Appeal (ECLI:NL:GHSHE:2025:1706). That court had provisionally found a turnover requirement for commission after the end of the agency to be incompatible with the Commercial Agents Directive.

The subdistrict court judge does not follow that approach. In the judge’s view, that case was materially different: there, the agent had exclusivity and received no fixed fee. Here, by contrast, the agent did receive a fixed fee. Because the contract referred to ‘continuing’ the commission, the threshold continued to apply. The French party did not sufficiently dispute the producer’s calculation, so €8,789 was awarded.

Goodwill compensation: whoever makes a claim must be specific

For goodwill compensation under Article 7:442 DCC, the agent must assert and, if necessary, prove that it brought in new customers or significantly expanded business with existing customers, and that the principal still derives substantial benefits from this after termination. The French company based its calculation on its fee for 2023 and a migration percentage, but did not name a single customer. It therefore failed to meet its duty to substantiate, and the claim was rejected. Each party was ordered to bear its own legal costs.

Conclusion

This judgment shows that a ‘no agency’ clause offers little protection if the relationship looks like agency in practice. For principals, this means: look at the remuneration structure, not at the title above the contract. A bonus that moves with turnover in the territory may already be enough.

For agents, the lesson is at least as sharp. Anyone who wants goodwill compensation must show, customer by customer, what they have built up. Anyone who does not keep their customer list up to date leaves a good claim on the table. You can read more about this in our earlier blog on goodwill compensation for commercial agents. AMS Advocaten previously represented a commercial agent successfully in an agency dispute before the District Court of North Holland (judgment).